Is Everything in the Bible There to Teach Us Something?

I framed this blog as a question, though I’ve quite often heard it expressed more as a statement: that everything in the Bible is, indeed, there to teach us something. Either way, let me first distinguish it from “Is everything in the Bible something we can learn from?” To this second question, the answer must surely be affirmative, though we shall need to qualify that in a moment. However, I have some serious reservations about the premise underlying the first.

Those reservations begin with something I’ve mentioned before: the flawed notion of the Bible being God’s Instruction Manual. I scarcely know where to begin unpicking that one.

To start with, the majority of Scripture is narrative—stories, in other words. Stories are not instructions, though of course they can be instructive. But what they are instructive concerning is another matter entirely. That depends on how we interpret them.

Parables are a classic example. They don’t interpret themselves. If anyone ever says that the meaning of a parable—what it’s “teaching”—is obvious, it’s almost certainly the case that they have missed the point. Or at least, missed the point as it would have been perceived by a first-century listener.    

In fairness, so many of Jesus’ parables are so well-known—and we’ve heard so many sermons about them—that it’s all very comfortable and familiar. It’s easy to assume that we know what a parable is about and who the characters are—which one is God in the story, which one is us, who’s the goody, who’s the baddy and so on. But that may well not have been how the original audience would have heard it, because parables were deliberately subversive. They led you to expect one thing and then turned it on its head.

So if we’re not finding something a bit odd, or even shocking—if nothing surprises us … If there are no “loose ends” … If we’re not left with any questions afterwards—we may well be hearing it wrong. The more “obvious” we think a parable is, the more we may be missing things.  

In the Parable of the Lost Sheep, when Jesus says, “Which of you with a hundred sheep who loses one doesn’t leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness to go after the one that’s lost?” we are nodding in agreement, because it’s Jesus saying it. But plenty of people listening at the time would be thinking, “No one would do that! It’s a stupid thing to do! Why would he say that?” 

Back to our original question. The flawed notion that everything in the Bible is there to teach us something leads to all manner of things being presented to us as what the Bible teaches. I don’t mean straightforward teaching such as Jesus saying “Love one another as I have loved you.” I mean the kinds of thing that I found in a quick search of Christian books on Amazon:

Business Secrets from the Bible: Spiritual Success Strategies for Financial Abundance. The authors have “extracted 40 business secrets from the pages of humanity’s most trusted volume. … In the book, you'll explore the secrets of creating revenue using timeless spiritual strategies…” Is that really what the biblical writers being quoted were writing about?

Not dissimilar sounding is 21 Laws of Money: Getting Rich The Biblical Way. You may have guessed already that this one is written by a “health and wealth, prosperity-gospel” type. In his words: “Do you know you can rich [sic] and still make heaven? Do you know God has not called you into a life of poverty but of affluence and abundance? Do you know there is a way to making money the godly way?” and so on. “Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, David, Boaz, and a host of other saints were rich, yet they made it to heaven. You too can be like them!” It’s easy enough to see the appeal of something like this, but it makes my blood boil (in a loving and gracious kind of way). One Pentecostal biblical scholar, Gordon Fee, called health and wealth prosperity gospel teaching a “disease.”

Then there’s Biblical Project Management. Yes, really. “This book is about biblical project management, principles, tools, techniques, and practices used by Nehemiah … in the re-building of the wall around Jerusalem and its revitalization.” Apparently, “It can be used as a manual for project recovery by project sponsors, owners, leaders, project managers and teams managing projects,” citing Nehemiah’s “incredible use of advanced project management tools and techniques … that he used to re-build the wall and achieve spiritual revival in Jerusalem.” Nice to see we get some revival as well; and all for only £17.16 (paperback).    

Moving on, we have The Maker's Diet. I suspect you’ve already guessed what this one will be claiming. As a young man suffering from various ailments, the author “found himself tearing through the pages of the world’s oldest, most sacred, and bestselling book—the Bible. What he found was a superb health plan that literally transformed his life and gave rise to The Maker’s Diet.” With a co-conspirator, the author has recently produced The Biblio Diet: Transforming Your Health the Way God Intended. Apparently, this is “based on the ancient wisdom of the Bible and confirmed by modern science.” As a little bonus, it includes “12 biblically inspired recipes.” Yummy.    

I should stop there, but I couldn’t resist adding this one: The Bible Cure for Irritable Bowel Syndrome. Actually, it’s a series of books. There are also books by the same author, all based on “ancient truths,” offering Bible Cures for Prostate Disorders, Allergies, Back Pain, Arthritis, and Diabetes. The next one in the series is The Bible Cure for Death. Actually that’s a joke. Or perhaps I should say that one is more of a joke.       

I suppose that for the Christian market the lure of something being tagged as “biblical” is enough to place its apparent wisdom over and above any “secular” writings about subjects like making money, project management, healthcare, or whatever.

Notice a pattern in the abundant use of phrases such as what God intended, compliments about the Bible’s ancient wisdom, the biblical way, the world’s oldest, most sacred, and bestselling book, and biblical secrets that are being made available to the punters who buy the books. All of these phrases are merely marketing slogans. The fact that the Bible may be the world’s bestselling book plainly has nothing whatsoever to do with any implication that The Maker’s Diet ought therefore to be number 2 on Amazon’s list.     

The whole idea of the Bible containing “secrets” that can be perceived by and revealed through special people (but unavailable to ordinary people) is reminiscent of Gnosticism—an ancient heresy concerning secret spiritual knowledge. However, when the New Testament talks about secrets and mysteries, it is almost invariably speaking of them having now been revealed in Christ, not concealed for a few anointed ones to discover 2,000 years later. And yet, for some reason, these gnostic ideas seem to be compelling for a certain Pentecostal and charismatic Christian audience.

For example, Colossians 1:26–27: “… the mystery that has been kept hidden for ages and generations, but is now disclosed to the Lord’s people. To them God has chosen to make known among the Gentiles the glorious riches of this mystery, which is Christ in you…” And Colossians 2:2–3: “My goal is that they may be encouraged in heart and united in love, so that they may have the full riches of complete understanding, in order that they may know the mystery of God, namely, Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge.” And Jesus in Matthew 13:11: “… the knowledge of the secrets of the kingdom of heaven has been given to you.”

I, too, would be a convert, if the secret knowledge on offer was this week’s winning National Lottery number. Then I wouldn’t need to buy the Spiritual Success Strategies for Financial Abundance book.         

There are so many problems with the things I’ve been describing, but I only have space to mention a couple.

A classic error in Bible reading is to assemble individual verses drawn from different parts of Scripture, extracted from their very different original contexts, effectively ignoring those contexts (and what they were saying to the writers’ original audiences at the time) and then stringing them together in some supposedly systematic way. Bible verses can never be extracted and read in that kind of flattened-out, context-free manner.

A further error, compounding that, is to read meanings and intentions into verses that simply were not present when those texts were originally written. We cannot say “The Bible says” (with an implied divine authority standing behind it) if what we’re claiming a text is “saying” is incompatible with the authors’ intentions. Sometimes I think that biblical writers would be astonished (they’d probably laugh at us) if they heard what’s sometimes being claimed.

Yes, of course, “meaning” in Scripture can go beyond that original contextual meaning—the Holy Spirit can speak to us through a text in ways that need not correspond to it—but we are straying into some potentially difficult territory that lends itself to all sorts of Pentecostal and charismatic nonsense being claimed as “biblical” through such proof texting.  

We should never forget that there is a chasm of difference between what a Bible verse or passage “says” (the words on the page) and what someone tries to claim that it’s “saying.” The latter is in the realm of interpretation (putting it kindly) and exposed to all kinds of misapplication.   

Next
Next

Guest Blog: A Loving Rebuke Concerning ‘Sin For Normal People’